Press Release

Victory for Nurses in Rest Break Arbitration Decision Against Sacred Heart Medical Center

SPOKANE, WA - 6/1/2006

The Washington State Nurses Association (WSNA), who represents nearly 1300 registered nurses at Sacred Heart Medical Center (SHMC), won an arbitration decision against SHMC for not providing 15 minute rest breaks for the nurses.  The collective bargaining agreement clearly provides for 15 minutes of rest every four hours.  Due to the recent restructure and inadequate staffing at SHMC, the nurses have not been getting their rest breaks.

According to the arbitrator’s decision, the collective bargaining contract “provides that 15–minute breaks shall be provided during each four-hour work period.  The arbitrator is at a loss to see how that language could be any clearer.  The word shall is mandatory; it allows for no managerial discretion whatsoever.”

In addition, the decision stated that “in order to provide quality care, the nurses need occasional rest breaks that allow them to attend to personal needs.  Simply drinking a glass of water or quickly using the bathroom does not suffice.”

The decision orders SHMC to:

  1. comply with the collective bargaining agreement and provide the required 15 minute breaks for the nurses.
  2. compensate each RN for missed breaks since August 3, 2004.

“We are thrilled with the decision because this is a patient safety issue.  Nurses must have the opportunity to take a break to refresh ourselves in order to provide the quality care that our patients deserve,” said Marty Avey, RN, Local Unit Chair.

“The average nurse in Washington is in her late 40’s and we simply cannot work 8 or 12 hours without a rest break and practice safely.  This decision sends a clear message to employers that they must provide for adequate staffing in order to ensure that nurses are able to take the rest breaks,” said Barbara E. Frye, RN, WSNA Director of Labor Relations.



Founded in 1908, WSNA is the professional organization representing more than 15,000 registered nurses in Washington State. WSNA effectively advocates for the improvement of health standards and availability of quality health care for all people; promotes high standards for the nursing profession; and advances the professional and economic development of nurses.

More Information

Washington State Nurses Association
575 Andover Park West, Suite 101
Seattle, WA 98188
206-575-7979 | 206-575-1908 Fax
WSNA Logo
© 2005-2010.   All rights reserved